Jamie Niederbaumer - Top Elm Grove and Brookfield Realtor

Meet Jamie!

Jamie Niederbaumer is not your typical realtor, and that’s why her clients love her. She measures her success — not by closings — but by the referrals and life-long relationships she forges. You’ll feel her commitment to service from your first interaction to long after the close.


Helping people find more than a house, Jamie focuses on finding the perfect-fit community – the schools, the neighborhood, the full vibe. It’s more than four walls (and a two-car garage), finding a home is about finding your place in this world. It’s a decision you don’t take lightly, and neither does Jamie.

Jamie is always thinking strategically - especially when writing offers and negotiating. She has advanced training and mentorship in clever and impactful ways to structure offers. She hangs her winning offers on her fridge next to her kids’ art – a celebration of the creative muscle it takes to stand out in a competitive market.

Prior to real estate, Jamie served the financial needs of her community at Vantage Financial with her husband Jesse. As a fiscal steward, Jamie takes her fiduciary responsibility for her clients seriously and believes that there’s a house for every budget.

Jamie lives in Elm Grove with her husband Jesse. The Niederbaumers have three awesome kids and a spunky doodle.

Service Above All

Service runs deeper than her career, Jamie is an Army veteran.  doesn't back down from tough negotiations or uphill battles. 

Today, Jamie is a serial volunteer in her community. She is always all-in, just ask her Daisy Troop, the Elm Grove Junior Guild, the Downtown Business Association, her church, and her kids' school.

  • "Jamie made the process extremely simple for us. We also appreciated her working with our timeline to keep things moving quickly."

    Josh & Alex, Elm Grove Buyers

  • "Jamie went above and beyond when helping us sell our home. We were selling due to divorce which was beyond hard. She was so compassionate."

    Waukesha Seller

  • "I simply can't say enough good things about Jamie. She's knowledgable, personable and professional all things you want your real estate agent to be."

    Kelly, Waukesha Buyer

  • "Jamie is the person you want by your side in this crazy market."

    Kelly S.

  • "I absolutely love Jamie. From start to finish she has been so patient with me and really took the time to sit down and explain everything. "

    Kayla, Jackson Buyer

  • "Jamie had a challenging task with us since we had to close in less than 4 weeks. We saw a lot of houses in a very short time but found one that was perfect for us. Jamie was key in that success.

    Bernadette & Kevin, Milwaukee

  • "Jamie is a great agent — she really went above and beyond. "

    Rita & Wes — Brookfield Buyers